Jun 27, 2006

Tale of Puttu and two events

I didn’t like puttu...oops! I uttered that word…that’s like a food crime in Kerala. Can you imagine an American saying ‘I don’t like cheese’?

What cheese is to America is what puttu is to a Malayalee. If you can read Malayalam, go to this blog specially made for all puttu fans. So you know how crazy Kerala is about puttu, especially since it is Kerala’s own simple and easy breakfast. I disliked puttu before marriage since what I tasted was always hard and chewy.

Since God is funny, my husband loves puttu! He loves to eat it 24/7. No kidding, but puttu enjoys a more important place in our house than yours truly. I think Malayalee wives can understand that plight of mine.

Now, for puttu you need a puttu-maker or at least a pressure cooker and a chiratta (coconut shell). To complicate things, there is even a Bamboo Puttu Maker:). There are many puttu recipes from fellow Malayalee bloggers like RP, Priya, Reshma and a lovely pictorial link from RP's blog.

But how will someone without all these gadgets make the simple puttu?

Puttu is just the simple process of steaming roasted rice. Yes, you don’t need a complicated puttu-maker, but just a close weaved strainer and a pot that would fit the strainer without leaving any gaps for the steam to escape, just like a steamer basket. It would be good to have a lid which fits the vessel with a hole on the lid for the steam to escape. Now, if you don’t have a lid also, fine, just close with aluminum foil and punch a small hole.

Now you can buy puttu flour at stores. But Ah! You don’t get the real flavour of freshly ground rice with that. This is an entry for For the Love of Rice and I wanted to make it from scratch, yes precisely for the love of rice. (If planning to buy puttu flour from stores, precisely look for 'Puttu Podi' or 'Puttu Flour')

Soak 1 cup of raw rice overnight. Strain the rice next day. Dry the rice completely on a flat tray with a paper towel on the try.drying soaked rice
When the rice is completely dry, dry roast it on low flame for 10 or 15 minutes. The rice should NOT turn brown nor it should change it’s color. It should be roasted until the rice becomes very brittle, that’s all.ground rice
Grind it in your clean spice grinder. You don’t grind it fine like ‘All Purpose Flour’ for puttu. A fine sooji like texture is also okay. Store them. This will store good for one week or so.This ground flour from one cup of rice will make puttu for 4 people.

The next part is to wet the flour. Add salt to the flour. Wet flour should have a texture of wet sand. But it should flow smoothly if you take the flour and drop it. To make this texture, Mix hot water into the flour. Try adding only 1 table spoon of hot water each time until the texture becomes like wet sand. You will get a fantastic aroma, when you wet the flour from freshly ground flour. Keep aside for 10 minutes.wet puttu flour before steaming
Now we are going to make puttu. When buying or selecting the strainer keep in mind that, grated coconut should not fall off from the strainer. Take ¼ cup of fresh grated coconut and spread it on the strainer like a base. Now add wet flour on top of the coconut. Then add ¼ cup of coconut.using strainer instead of puttu gadgetssteaming puttu with close lid
Steam this with closed lid. Make sure the steam doesn’t escape. Cover with kitchen towel on the sides if your strainer doesn’t fit properly. Steam this for 15 minutes. Make sure the strainer bottom doesn’t touch the water in the pot.After 15 minutes of steaming, open lid and take off from heat and flip the strainer with the puttu on to a plate.Serve with bananas, boiled plantains, papad, boiled moong dal, kadala curry or anything you can imagine. I like it with some Fish Curry.

You can add cardamom powder or cumin powder to the puttu flour before steaming to make it aromatic.

I think someone named Ann posted a comment asking me, whether we can make puttu without coconut. Of course! It is upto you. The layering of puttu is protein – carbs – protein - carbs. So instead of coconut, add beans or meat any other protein you would like to add. Anything which you want to steam. I have never tried it, but have heard people trying it. So do at your own risk ;-)

Though innocuous to look at, puttu is a very heavy breakfast. So eat only half the quantity of what you think you can eat.Now what other entry is good for lovely Nandita’s Breakfast Event, than some God’s own puttu?

9 comments:

Inji Pennu said...

37 Comments:
At 28/6/06 12:21 AM, Aparna said...
That lovely puttu story!! we fry rice powder after grinding the rice into powder. Sometimes i do add grated carrot partition to break up puttu. I have tried with mixing left over chicken curry.. very tasty it comes out!

At 28/6/06 12:29 AM, archanat said...
Here's another post with LG written all over it. My appreciation for Puttu has ofcourse increased so much over the years. I just love my mother's special "banana puttu". My god, i am going to stop right here, i will end up writing an essay otherwise. I enjoyed this post so much, Thank you. BTW, i was not able to see couple of photos in this post. Is it a problem or is it just me ?

At 28/6/06 12:44 AM, Paz said...
How very interesting! I like the sound of this recipe. Thanks for making it from scratch and sharing it with us!

Paz

At 28/6/06 1:03 AM, Linda said...
LG, that truly looks like a labor of rice love. The photos of freshly ground flour are especially nice. Did you write something in the flour, or is it a design, or just showing the texture? Whatever it is, the photos are great -- thanks for showing step-by-step how this is made.

At 28/6/06 1:36 AM, Immigrant in Canada said...
Roasting the rice before grinding was a super idea.. I always ground the rice first and then roasted the flour!!!..
BTW: the first time I made puttu.. I stuffed and packed my puttukutti with flour..after an hour of steaming and no steam coming out from the top, I took the kutty off from the pot and turned it upside down and thondiffied the puttu and ate!!! the rest of the puttu that still remained inside the kutty.. I was able to remove after 24 hrs of complete water immersion!!

At 28/6/06 5:03 AM, indianadoc said...
This was what exactly I used to do till I got hold of my puttu maker from home...Malayalis never get tired of eating Puttu and talking about puttu...I too cdnt help blogging abt it quite some time ago...Next time I go home I'm going to sneak out my mom's bamboo puttu maker!!

At 28/6/06 5:06 AM, renuramanath said...
LG, thank you for the link to puttu fans. really funny. you are really great, to start from scratches ! we usually make and store the rice powder in bulk. it is a main routine chore in my parents' home. at least 2 -3 kgs. of rice, washed adn sent to the local mill, brought back home, and roasted, before storing. i usually bring my arippodi from home. can't trust the store-bought rice powders after read something about a novel way of adding the flour of some toxic, wild fruit to the rice flour.
the varieties of puttu are infinite. but, my fav combo is plain, puttu-pazham-pappadam, with a sprinkling of sugar if you feel like it. nothing to beat that.

At 28/6/06 5:59 AM, Sumitha Shibu said...
I too dont like putt LG and luckily for me my husband hates it even more.
My mum makes different types of puttu,rice wheat ragi and they are all soft and all my friends used to love them.I used to pack a dabba of puttu for them and something else for me for lunch whenever we have puttu for breakfast.I find it so difficult to swallow it!
Its been almost a year since i ate puttu,now i am missing it for the first time.

It was very nice of you to post the recipe this way specially for the many who dont have a puttkutti.

At 28/6/06 7:45 AM, Krithika said...
I love this step-by-step detailed narration. Excellent LG !

At 28/6/06 7:56 AM, Annita said...
Roasting before grinding..Thats a wonderful idea L.G.And ur idea of preparing it without a Puttukutti needs real appreciation.I would have never thought of that..

At 28/6/06 8:37 AM, RP said...
Oh LG!!! You did it again.
You have an alternative for everything. :)
I do have a puttu maker that sits on top of the cooker, but I want to try it with the strainer next time. I can pretend like I made it in chiratta!
Indeed a wonderful entry for the event.

At 28/6/06 9:05 AM, starry nights said...
Lg..thank you for sharing this very inovative way of making puttu. I love puttu very much especially with cocnut and sugar.oh I forgot the banana.the pics are awesome. I was wondering where I would get a bamboo putu maker but now you have solved that dilema. thanks again.

At 28/6/06 10:54 AM, Ashwini said...
I had a Mallu friend in school and was familiar with meen/ karimeen and avial and what not. But I NEVER got to eat puttu. Damn I should have gone to her home early in the morning :-)
Eversince Priya and Reshma posted about it I have wanted to try this. Thanks for showing it can be done without the gadget too. Next on my list LG

At 28/6/06 10:54 AM, Indu said...
I haven't gone through your Puttu tale, but as I read the first line I knew those were kindred emotions! I don't like puttu either and have always wondered what people find in puttu that I don't. Actually, once I read a food column on Bollywood hottie John Abhraham and how his fave breakfast item was Puttu and chutney (!!!)and the heat he was generating on screen slowly died down! The sight of puttu in the morning always puts me in a bad mood. Now will go back and read what you have to say about puttu.

At 28/6/06 10:59 AM, indu said...
Since God is funny, my husband loves puttu!

Everytime I make faces at the breakfast table about not liking Puttu, this i what I am told how my fate will be!

At 28/6/06 1:30 PM, Priya said...
I have been to kerala a number of times, Most of my friends are Mallu's, Been to thier homes for breakfast, lunch, dinners. But when they serve me puttu, its a big " NO - I DONT LIKE PUTTU " As if i have tasted it before :)

But now your story of puttu and the pictures are tempting me to try atleast once to decide if i like it or not. Shall give it a try and let u know how i liked it.

At 28/6/06 1:59 PM, Nabeela said...
that's an interesting recipe...and you are very innovative with your strainer ;)

At 28/6/06 5:29 PM, Priya Bhaskaran said...
Wow LG, your so innovative... I appreciate your ideas. I am a big fan of Puttu with kadala curry and pappadam...hmm yummy, on the other hand my husband doesn't have much liking towards puttu.. he feels it is hard to eat and often he has to gulp water to clear his throat... so funny:) I couldn't enjoy puttu after marriage as I enjoyed before at my home. I don't make puttu quite often these days since he doesn't like it... it is so hard to make just for me:(

At 28/6/06 8:51 PM, Anonymous said...
"The layering of puttu is protein – carbs – protein - carbs."

My dear blogger, where in puttu do u find protein?. Do u mean to say coconut is full of protein? Please don't leave such misleading comments if U r unsure of the fact.

At 28/6/06 9:10 PM, L G said...
dear anonymous,

Sorry to mislead you,but as far as I know grated coconut contains proteins just like vegetables but in different amounts. Rice is full of carbs and along with coconut it makes a whole meal. Thats the idea.

At 28/6/06 9:34 PM, Indira said...
That's one terrific post, LG. Thanks for sending me the link.
I wish I'd have a taste before trying out. Oh well... I'll start with a small batch, perhaps a small cup to see how I like it.

You have written "puttu" in Malayalam on rice ravva, right? Linda was asking about it.

Anonymous: 1 cup of shredded coconut contains 2.7g of protein, according to this link. That's enough protein for a breakfast item, don't you think?

If you have any other information that we don't know about coconut, enlighten us.
Thanks!

At 29/6/06 1:40 AM, കലേഷ് | kalesh said...
എല്-ജീ, കിടിലം!
പുട്ട് ഫാന്സ് അസ്സോസ്സിയേഷനിലേക്ക് സുസ്വാഗതം!
പുട്ട് ഫാന്സ് അസ്സോസ്സിയേഷനിലേക്ക് ഒരു ഇന്വിറ്റേഷന് അയച്ചുതരുന്നതിനായി ദയവായി ഈ-മെയില് അഡ്രസ്സ് adeign(at)gmail(dot)com എന്ന വിലാസത്തിലേക്ക് അയച്ചുകൊടുക്കാമോ?

At 29/6/06 3:53 AM, ann said...
Hey LG,

So here you are with your own special post for puttu! I will always remember you whenever I make puttu. Guess what, I ve become an expert.Just want to share with everyone a useful tip that I learned from my mom. While wetting the flour there are chances of forming lumps. If there are lumps, then put the wetted mix little by little in a grinder or multimixie and switch it on for about 2 secs (my mixie is very powerful). This will remove the lumps and you get a smooth and consistent mixture.

love,
ann.

At 29/6/06 1:31 PM, Anonymous said...
This is Vidya, not the Original Anonymous:

India and LG - Accept when you make a mistake. As you say 1 cup of Coconut has 2.7g of Protein. Have you noticed that 1 cup of rice has 4.2g of Protein, making it the Protein source of the dish, not Coconut. Maybe you should have paid attention to the link Indira posted, it clearly states that "Foods that are a “good source” of a particular nutrient provide between 10 and 20% of the USDA Recommended Daily Value.", so neither Coconut nor Rice are good sources of protein.

At 29/6/06 1:42 PM, L G said...
Dear Vidya,

I have no problems in correcting a mistake. But I still think you dont get the idea of what I meant in the post.

When we eat cooked rice (even though rice has protein), with curries - i.e. what we do, Carbs and protein. Rice has more carbs,
and vegetables or meat has protein.

I mean, C'mon we are not going to count how much milligram of carbs and protein each stuff has before we eat. I dont count it,do you?

The idea of puttu is also the same. Rice with some protien. Thats all I was saying. Indira was showing you the link because you specifically talked about the amount of protein in coconut.

You can be first anyonymous, second anonymous or whatever,I really don't mind. Don't worry, I am not going to compare and check the IP address of each comment.I really dont mind as long as the comment follows some basic decency.
That's all! I can also delete the comments in my blog if it happens.

I hope you won't get worked up about this matter at all. Leave it. Be happy.

At 29/6/06 2:02 PM, Anonymous said...
I don't sit around "worrying" as you put it, that you'd look up my ip address - I was clarifying that my posting is not by the same person who posted as Anonymous earlier. It is your blog, and your prerogative to delete comments as you wish. As a savvy web user I'm quite aware of this and there is no need to use it as a threat to stop me from writing more comments on your blog. FYI, deleting comments that provide you with scientific information which apparently you weren't earlier aware of, is a reflection of you getting all worked up.

I could write more about how being aware of the carb/protein/fat content of ingredients will help you and your readers eat healthy, but of course you don't seem to be receptive to learning. So long...

At 29/6/06 2:11 PM, L G said...
Take it easy dear anonymous. Did it feel like a threat to you? Sorry about it.

Eating healthy? Hmm…Looks like you are a health police counting carbs, proteins etc. Sorry to disappoint you, but my dishes I wouldn’t consider epitome of health nutrition etc. I am just blogging for the fun of it. Just enjoying my recipes with some friends with similar tastes. That’s all!

Since it looks like you have some great information, please do blog about it and I will be happy to read your blog and try to adjust my recipes if I find them healthy.

Peace!

At 29/6/06 7:23 PM, L G said...
Aparna, I have never tried with vegetables.I have ahd puttu with beef. Yummy!

archana, Post about it dear.You can write an essay here and I would love to read it.

paz, My pleasure.

Linda, I wrote 'ari' which means Rice in My Langauge and script.But the top photo didnt come out good.
Thankyou for your kind words.

Sarah, hehehe..thondified? you talk like my little niece. ee penninte oru kaaryam!

shynee,I have never even seen a babmoo puttu maker. Saw the khadi shop comment.will try next time i go back home.

renu, I really appreciate every comment from you. You are so knowledgeable and such a nice writer.

sumitha, yes. I want to globalize puttu :)

krithika, thank you for your kind words always.

annita, thank you so much.

rp, yeah! it really looks like made in chiratta

starry nights, I am glad to hear that I solved something.finally:)

ashwini, you had a chance to eat puttu and missed it? Cant blv that!! Now I think you should make it :)

Indu, heheh.Yeah! I am sure your fate is going to be similar.

Priya, Try once.So you can decide whether you like it or not.

nabeela, thanks :)

priya, if thats the case, make puttu with fine rice powder not puttu powder. It will be soft,very soft.

indira, thank you so much.Your compliments are so precious to me.
I wrote അരി which means rice in malayalam.

ann, thank you for the tip! Glad to know that you became an expert and your puttuless days are bygone!

At 29/6/06 10:08 PM, Anonymous said...
Dear IG & Indira, One needs to take approx 50 gms of protein a day(more accuracy can be obtained if the person's weight is known. So, if 1 cupof coconut is used & it gives 3 gms of protein & if the meal is shared by 2 persons, each one gets around 1.5 gms of protein...not even 1/10th of daily req. Also, vegs are not rich source of protein(their protein content are negligeble). It's the dhals & meat which are rich source of protein. So, U can decide if it's right to say "The layering of puttu is protein – carbs – protein - carbs" when coconut is used.

IG, it doesn't matter if U count on the carb, protein content in your food. But please see to it that you don't post comments which might be misleading.

P.S: I'm the anonymous who posted before Vidhya

At 30/6/06 4:23 AM, renuramanath said...
LG, well said about what the anonymous said. for god's sake, do keep out this carb/protien/vitamins business out of your beautiful site that contains a lot of worthy information ! and, i don't think our anscestors added coconut to puttu for its 'protein content' but for its TASTE, man ! can you replace the aroma of steamed coconut mingled with the steamed rice powder with anything else in the world ?!
we indians, (at least those who were lucky enough to eat good), never have had to worry about counting the carb/protein contents. our food naturally contained all these balancing elements. LG, the food you and me grew up eating is one of the healthiest foods in the world, if you manage to keep out the recent trend of eating chicken fry and fish fry everyday. well, more of the cooking styles, in my blog, soon.

At 30/6/06 6:36 AM, Anonymous said...
"i don't think our anscestors added coconut to puttu for its 'protein content' but for its TASTE, man !"- renuramanath

Absolutely what I meant to say... Since lg's comment was misleading, I just wanted to point it out...

At 30/6/06 7:25 AM, L G said...
Dear Anonymous,
You still dont get what Renu is saying. What she is saying is our ancestors formulated this food for specific reasons. They took care of both nutrients and taste without any protien/carb calcualtion which is the current fad now.

And let me tell you something, you can be the president of U.S FDA, but I would respect my ancestors wisdom, since it is not tainted with any pharma money.

Until now, I thought you were genuine even though the way you commented was not the proper way. But now it looks like you are just trying to create some trouble.
Esp, when I saw your comment about vegetables etc. So please be kind and leave me alone and please dont eat any puttu. If you dont want coconut, dont eat it. I feel you are against coconut. So be it.
Please dont comment anymore.
Thanks.

At 30/6/06 9:20 AM, Anonymous said...
LG, That was a great post in true LG style : humorous, informative and with lots of relevant pics that makes u try out the recipe immediately.... I dint have the appropriate strainer etc but was determined to try it out.. drilled a hole in a coconut shell and tried.. came out great.. thanks again. -Mary

At 30/6/06 11:58 PM, Anonymous said...
That's funny,LG. I don't understand what's wrong in my comment on vegs. I said the fact.Anyways, I am not against coconut & I do use it in my cooking. It's only that I wanted to point out a fact abt it. It's upto the reader to accept it or not.

Anyways, there's nothing to be angered abt in a discussion. If U don't want me to comment it, be it. Bye.

At 1/7/06 12:07 AM, L G said...
Hi anonymous,
I was not angered.
I did'nt feel right about the tone of your 'misleading' comment.I mean, to simply state a weighty word 'misleading' .
That way,you can find hundreds of your type of 'misleading' info in my dishes. Also you didnt get the gist of protein/carb combination.

Also there is a common courtesy of leaving your name etc if you leave a post like that.Don't you think so?

The way you commented now, the last one is quite nicely and a pleasant one. Even if you criticise,if you do it nicely I think it would be nice instead of spit and run comments like the first one.

At 1/7/06 4:33 AM, സ്വാര്ത്ഥന് said...
Dear LG,
I don't want to tell U, 'What a nice post', 'Lovely', 'beautiful', 'Marvellous', 'Blah', Blah', 'Blah'.

But would like to give this warning: U BETTER SEND US Ur EMAIL ID and ACCEPT THE INVITATION TO POST TO puttans.blogspot.com

Otherwise.....

LUV,
Swarthan
(adeign@gmail.com)

At 16/8/06 11:14 PM, Anonymous said...
My mom used to make graet kelvaragu (ragi) puttu. Can u blog about it?

Anonymous said...

Hi Friends , Join Orkut Community
PuttuPremikal

Anonymous said...

americans don't know what real cheese is. all they know is cheddar and that's pasteurized plastic crap. hand an american a stilton or some roquefort and he'll probably run the other direction. do you even know what real cheese is, probably not as you don't have much in india (or wherever you come from, unlike us Swiss, French, etc. very bad comparison here.

Anonymous said...

I liked this recipe very much:-)Thanks fr sharing...

Anonymous said...

I love puttu. When I was young my mom used to make this often I miss that so much. I like to eat puttu with just sugar. Heaven.

Your post brought so many wonderful memories of my childhood. Thank you.

Rumya

Anonymous said...

Hello LG: I had bought a ready-made puttu flour (with red rice) and twice failed at getting the right texture (and that too without a puttu maker). I followed your beautiful instructions and also did it in my idli plate. Wonderful! It is exactly like what my neighbour back home (she's from nagercoil and makes puttu every other day) pampered me with. Thanks a lot LG. PS: I kept a slice of banana in the layering itself and my boy ate quite a satisfying quantity (and he's a fussy eater)

Jen Kumar said...

Amazing creativity. Now any American can make puttu to with local pots and pans! :) You are an innovative person.

I have linked this article on my puttu recipe here
http://shakahaari.blogspot.com/2008/06/chiratta-puttu-with-kadala.html

Nanni

Anonymous said...

ralph Lauren polo shirts , Lacoste Polo Shirts, Burberry Polo Shirts.wholesale Lacoste polo shirts and polo ralph laurenwith great price. clothingol.com offers lot of 10 lacoste polo shirts and lot of 20 cheap polo shirts. clothingol.com offers classic fit polo shirts. polo clothing All our shirts made in original factory.
nike air max ltdFree Shipping,50%OFF,Accept Paypal.We offer cheap converse NIKE air shoes , cheap adidas shoes, adidas stan smith,cheap nike shoes, cheap puma mens shoes , enjoy shopping!

ബാലചന്ദ്രൻ ചുള്ളിക്കാട് said...

it is believed that puttu is a portuguese contribution to our food culture.